Is Your Shia Friend Asking You Questions?

Replies to Questions by Shias and a review of their beliefs

Understand the Shia Game Plan


Assalamu Alaykum, my brothers and sisters in Islam.

OK…So you have a shia friend and he/she is asking you questions about the Islamic History and now you are searching the internet for sunni side explanations…You friend will tell you that this and this happend in history and they will give you references to your own books like Bukhari, Muslim etc or they will ask you questions wanting you to explain why this event happend …. they will want you to discuss and explain events like

  • Ghadir Khumm
  • Burial of Prophet Muhammad sallalahu alayhe wasallam
  • Issue of Fadak
  • The Event of Pen and Paper
  • The Event of the Saqifa
  • The hadith of the cloak
  • Assault on Fatima (r)
  • Fatima’s anger with Abu Bakar (r)
  • The Battle of Siffin and Battle of Jamal
  • Tragedy of Karbala
  • Attitude of Muawiyah and Yazid
  • etc etc….

SO WHATS  THE CATCH?? By discussing these events they will thus try to prove to you that the companions of Prophet Muhammad sallalahu alayhe wasallam were not loyal to him(naazuzobillah), that Ali (r)  was the most virtueous and had many distinctions while other sahaba had no distinctions and thus he was the chosen Caliph by Muhammad (s) and that he and his family ‘ the ahle bait’ were persecuted by the other companions, his caliphate was snatched away, all the other Sahaba  apostated and THUS  the sunni Islam is wrong and Shia Islam is the truth! and lo and behold you will stupidly convert to Shiasm and  marry your shia boyfriend/girlfriend.

TIME UP! OPEN YOUR EYES!!!

The basis of any religion is its belief system – the Aqaidh (Creed) and not events of history.  First of all the Shias are fed and brainwashed since their childhood and they are fed the ‘fabricated history’ which has been spun by the shias. The events and issues mentioned above all have logical explanations and most of all the history presented to you by  the Shia is highly distorted. You will find the Truth in non shia books of history …however, the point is that these issues are ir-relevent and leads to nothing but endless debates.

These events and their explanations are  answered in the ~Questions on History~ section of this blog.

Now.. if for the sake of argument, you accept the shia versions of history and accept the events as the shia say happened, this in no way proves that the Twelver Shia Islam is the right version of Islam. Why you may ask…because.. read carefully this is important.. the other sects of shias also believe in the above events of history, but they are not twelver shias. Do you know who these other sects are? They are Boris, Agha Khanis/Ismailies and zaidis. Do you know whats the difference amongst them? Its Immamat  The 12er shias claim that there are 12 imams and they were appointed by Allah and  the twelfth one is in hiding, but the Agha Khanis say that the chain of Imams has continued till this day and Prince Karim Agha Khan is the present day Imam and the Immamat did not end at the 12th hidden Imam..then there are Zaidis who only believe in the first five Imams. !! Plus there were many many sects of shias which have faded and everytime their imam died they fell into dispute as to who should be the next imam and this led to creation of many sects among them! So the main thing to prove shisam is their concept of Immamat.

1. Who chose the imams and how?

2. If Ali chose Hasan to be Imam, then shouldn’t  Hasan’s son be the next Imam? Why did Hussain become the next Imam and who chose him? (raduallahu anhum)

3. Why did the Immamat continue in the sons of Hussain and not Hasan? (r)

4. What was the purpose of having Imams after the Prophethood had ended? Wasn’t the Quran left behind enough?

5. If the purpose was to keep the mankind on the right path,then why did the 12th Imam disappear into hiding?

6. Can the shias prove the concept of Immamat from the Quran if it is such a major pillar of shia belief?

The shia concept of Immamat has been analysed and reviewed here

Another aspect to which the shias themsleves are oblivious to and are unable to explain is their twelfth imam. They know he is the imam and he is in hiding, but who was he really and how and why did he go into hiding? About this.. the shias have spun fairly tales which will take you into dream land and astonishingly none of the amazing miracles attributed to the 12th imam are even hinted at in the Quran! So you will have to believe the fairy tales the shias tell you without any proof what so ever! Their 11th Imam Hasan Al Askari dies at the age of 22 leaving no male heir. Shias don’t know what to do now…many sects of shias developed and one of them came up with the amazing story of a union between Hasan Al Askari and a roman slave girl, how she became pregnant and gave birth the same day! Here is a detailed article on the myth of the 12th Imam.

Apart from the unexplained system of choosing of Imams and the mystery of the 12th Imam… the main issue where Shias and Ahlus Sunnah differ is the system of belief i.e. the creed and most importantly Tawheed. Shirk, which is the opposite of  Tawheed is deeply prevalent in Shiaism. One simple example is that they call out to their Imam for help by stating Ya Ali Madad, Ya Abbas.. Ya Hussain.. even though Allah has told us to call HIM ALONE for help. Iyaaka Naa’budu wa iyaka Nasteen. You Alone We Worship and You Alone we ask for help.

The Shias tend to hide their real beliefs and avoid any discussion to do with the main fundamentals upon which the shia religion is based. So they raise historical questions that are based on  mostly concocted lies or what they assume to be sins or errors committed by the Sahaba in order to give them a bad name.

One should have a very very clear picture of the beliefs and fundamentals of the Shia religion before discussing these events. We are not avoiding answering the shias when it comes to these events.. they have been thoroughly answered here…but the main thing which separates Sunni from the Shia religion is the fundamental beliefs. Please see the section ~Shia Beliefs~ One should especially note their beliefs regarding Allah and their Imams and it should suffice that Shiasm is a religion based on shirk.

One thing that I found astounding when interacting with shias was they were very well aware about the events mentioned above but they have no clue what’s in their own hadith books. Infact apart from Nahjul Balagha, they don’t even know the names of their own hadith and fiqh books!

Many things negating the shia beliefs are found in the book “Nahjul Balagha” a book containing the sermons of Ali radiallahu anhuma. The source of this book is unknown and its authenticity is questionable so just like the Bible it contain sermons of Ali, some of which appear to be fabricated and some appear to be the real words of Ali as they are aggreable to Quran and Sunnah. The sermons of Ali are shared in sections ~Sermons of Ali ~ I have further classified these sermons as ‘True Words’ – and ‘Lies and Contradictions’. Amazingly one can find Pure Tawheed as found in the Quran and Sunnah in the sermons of Ali and in the same book the ‘lies’ attributed to Ali are full of shirk and deviation.

A new section has been added “Questions that led the Shia Youth to the Truth” which includes excerpts from the book by the same title. It is aimed at calling the attention of the intellectual among the shias to come to reason and ponder upon these questions that will help them revert to the real religion of Muhammad Sallalahu Alayhewasallam. One should therefore read them with an open mind for they are addressed to the inner self.

Another good section is “Must Read Books” which lists down excellent resources for deeper study and understanding of this issue and for some download link is also provided

It is hoped that this blog will lead you to explore the Shia religion further and realize the shirk and deviation of this religion disguised as Islam.

May Allah guide us ALL to the Deen of our beloved Prophet Muhammad Sallalahu Alayhewasallam so we are able to drink from his hands from the Haud e Kauther on the day of Judegement. Ameen

38 Responses to “Understand the Shia Game Plan”

  1. Syed Jaffer said

    who said to you that we call for help by saying ya abbas ya ali ya hussain we don’t do this don’t put your false judgements over the reality,it is strongly made clear by our scholars the one who worship other than Allah is not considered a muslim for example: if someone consider Hazrat Ali(A.S) as a god then he is not a muslim Because Allah is the only one to whom all muslim worship and Muhammad(p.b.u.h) was his last prophet this is the final belief of all Muslims the difference comes after the death of prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h) it is a endless debate but plz don’t try to put false judgements

    PEACE PLEASE

  2. Muslimfriend said

    To the author of this page. You wrote questions for the Shia friend. Not answers. You don’t know anything more than they do.

  3. vasz said

    The Suffering of the Ahl ul Bayt and their Followers (Shia) throughout History

    Imam Baqir (as) said “Since the death of the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) we Ahl ul bayt have been humiliated, made distant and have been deprived and killed and made to leave our home town and we felt frightened for our blood and the blood of our followers. The cheaters, through their lies, got nearer to the leaders, judges and governors in every city and our enemies told false and invalid traditions relating to their past leaders and quoted riwayah (narrations) that we had never told.
    They only wanted to humiliate us and wanted to accuse us of falsehood, and wanted to get nearer to their leaders through lies. After the passing away of Hasan (a.s) this became very common during thetime of Muawiyah. At that time, in every city, Shias were killed, their hands and feet were cut off and they were hanged on accusations of their being near to us and talking about their love for us.
    Then after that adversities increased in numbers and strength, from the martyrdom of Husayn (a.s) until the time of ibn Ziyad. Then came Hajjaj and he killed them (Shia of Ali) for every doubt and accusation until it was said that this person (Shia) was Zindiq (atheist) and majusi (Zoroastrian) and Hajjaj liked it better that these words be used rather than say that they were Shia of Husayn, peace be upon him.”

    Study and see how the Family of the Holy Prophet (sawa) were treated after the martyrdom of our beloved Prophet (sawa). How the Prophet (sawa) was poisoned, How his beloved daughter Fatima (as) was crushed behind the door, whipped and made to miscarriage her unborn son Muhsin (as) all while they were setting fire to her house while her children the masters of the youths of paradise Hassan (as) and Hussain (as) were inside.

    How they stole her land of Fadak and source of income as a way to put economic sanctions on them. How Imam Ali (as) was made to suffer under the rule of these oppressive rulers who stole his rights and then eventually killed him by a fatal blow of a sword while he was in prostration to his Lord.

    How they tortured and killed his followers, the shia, by cutting out their tongues, burying them alive inside of walls, crucifying them, exiling them, cutting off their heads and the list goes on. How they poisoned Imam Hassan (as) then obstructed his body from being buried beside his Grandfather the Messenger of Allah (sawa). How they Brutally massacred Imam Hussain (as), his family, friends and even his 6 month old baby, while all of them had been without food and water for three consecutive days.

    How they imprisoned his women and children and made them march in chains from Karbala to the prison of Damascus while whipping them and with all of the heads of their loved ones mounted on spears in the front of the army of these devils. How all of the Imam’s to follow, except Imam Mahdi (atf), were all killed by poison.

    “Surely those who tormented the believing men and the believing women and then did not repent, theirs shall be the chastisement of Hell, and theirs shall be the chastisement of burning.” Quran 85:10 In this brief attempt I have compiled different excerpts to make a summary and to inform the masses of the oppressive events that took place to the Ahl-ul- Bayt (family of Muhammad) and their Shia (followers). I have included all of the books that I referenced for this project so that you may study them. I hope that you as the reader benefit from this work and that you grow closer to our Imam’s, inshAllah (God willing). Mateen J. Charbonneau

    https://archive.org/stream/TheSufferingOfTheAhlUlBayt6X9/The%20Suffering%20of%20the%20Ahl%20ul%20Bayt%206%20x%209_djvu.txt

  4. Sakina said

    Salamun Alaykum,
    I would lyk to ask my sunni brother/sister who have posted the above article..

    why do Able Sunnat avoid the topics (mentioned in the starting of article) and then they blame shias for discussing such topic..why don’t the ahle sunnat give answers to these topics????

    the point said that why is imamate only from imam Hussain (as) progeny ..
    I would lyk to give u some of info ..

    the Shiites 4th Imam ..Ali ibn Hussain (as) the son of Imam Hussain (as) was married to Imam Hasan’s (as) daughter Fatema binte hasan..The son of 4th Imam ..Imam Mohammed Baqir (as) is the grandson of Imam Hussain as well as Imam Hasan..So the progeny from 5th Imam ..Imam Mohammed Baqir (as) are the sons of Imam Hasan as well as Imam Hussain..

    so pls don’t make a false issue that the imamate is nly from Imam Hussain (as)

  5. Sakina Nazarali said

    Assalmun Alaikum,
    For all of you who have read what the author of this site has to say, I sincerely respect your opinions and your views.
    However, to all the accusations you have made, and all the comments that have been made against the shia on this page, for the knowledge of yourselves and for the knowledge of others, for the respect of yourself and for the respects of this two muslim sects, I advice you to go and read Peshawar Nights, you can get an online copy from here https://archive.org/details/PeshawarNights.
    About 80% of the questions that sunnis have regarding the shia faith and the accusations our sunni brothers make, they are all answered here.
    The book is regarding a shia scholar who debated against 5 of the most learned scholars of the Sunni Sect in Peshawar for several nights. The debate is recorded in the document. After the debate, one of the sunni scholar decided to convert. Please sunni brothers and sisters, do not doubt on the Shia and make enmity, for we are all muslims. Whether you believe in our ways or not, at the end of the day, we are all followers of the Prophet and Allah(swt). Never will you see a Christian Lutheran arguing with a Christian Roman Catholic, neither should we. Lets be united. And if there are any queries, and answers you need, read the book: Peshawar Nights.

    Jazakallah.

  6. Rizwan said

    Assalam-o-alikum
    Dear brother and sister,

    I have studied shia religion in greater detailed and also made conversation with my old classmate who is still shia. First, of all these comments will be in very deatiled.
    —- The Shia religion is basically a jews fabricated religion.
    —- There sources are mainly nothing
    —- In shia religion Quran is (Summa Muazzallah) had been altered. Which is totally kuffar. In their sources round about more then 2000 hadiths fabricated from their imams. Although, these people From Hazrat Ali R.A to Hazrat Hassan askari R.A have no concern with them. They only use their name to promote jews dajjal goverment plan. The concept of 12th imam is same as they are waiting the arrival of him which never born in past. jews are waiting for dajjal and they are waiting for their fabricated imam. So similarity exist.
    —– Their sources are ‘ Assol al kafi’, and their other hadith books.
    —– They have belief to do ‘takkiya’ with other muslim. So one can never trust shia.
    —– They quoted controversial statements which completely deny their own arguments.
    —– Hazrat hassan R.A relinquish in favor of Muawiya R.A. This statement is mention in book ‘ Nahjul balagha’ . Hazrat hassan R.A made curse on them who said we are shia of ali r.a .
    —- Hazrat hussain had been assassinated by shia not by yazeed. It is mention in Assol kafi. Also another statement in this book is that ‘ Prophet Mohammad (SAW) said to Ali R.A ‘ O! Ali defend yourself and your progeny from people who call themselves that we are shia of Ali R.A’ this is mention in book volume 2 and 3.
    —– If a person wants to know about shia religion following books are very useful for every one.

    – Alshia and sunnah By ‘Allama Ehsan Elahi zaheer’
    -Alshia and Quran By ‘Allama Ehsan elahi zaheer’
    — haqiqat-e- mazhab shia by ‘Faiz Alam sadiqqi’
    —Ayat-e- bayennat by ‘ nawab mohsinul mulk’. He converted to sunni from shia was very famous figure from pakistan movement.
    — Various sermons and books of molana haq nawaz jhanqvi and azam tarik

  7. hasaan said

    Dear Brother,

    Please right an article on shias claiming to be sayyids…i think that you already know that its a fashion statement amongst shias to be sayyids(descendants of prophet muhammad pbuh)

  8. AlhSunnah said

    I have a friend who has unfortunately been swayed to the shia side, but I came in search of the truth to help her. Also they claim the treaty between Hasan and Muwiyah was on the condition it wud be given back to them after him but he broke the treaty and gave it to Yazid, also giving me some references, what evidence do we have to refute this.

  9. Hassan said

    To Mirza Ali and the rest of Shias.

    I really want to dig deeper in your fabricated stories. I love the way you Shias like to say “even the sunnah ulema believe in the shia sources etc etc ” Well its like saying if a christian came up to me and said the typical selling points of his religion and then converted me into his religon….

    Anyway, let me come to the point.

    Do you agree on that imam ali was Infallible?
    Did imam Ali himself making decisions or was he guided by Allah?
    Then why did Imam Ali pledge bayaah to hazrat Umar and Abu baqar?
    Why did imam ali’s son imam Hasan pledge bayaah to Muawiyah?

    This is what a shia will typically answer:
    *Imam Ali was forced to make pledge to Hazrat Umar and abu baqar*
    Oh so your saying that imam Ali was weak and he made the decision of having no choice but to plegde to hz.umar and abu baqar.

    Well if this is going to be your answer, then imam Ali is unfortunately not Infallible because according to Shias a person becomes munafiq if you have any kind of relations with Hz.Umar and Abu baqar.

    A another answer from Shia can be:
    *Imam Ali never gave bayaah to hz.Umar and Abu baqar*
    Well think twice before you say this, because i can prove easily it from your shia hadees sources book that Imam did not only pledge bayaah to hz.Umar and abu baqar but also to Muawiyah!

    So if you do go by the answer of that imam ali was guided by Allah, then its being proved by itself that Hazrat umar and Abu abuqar were the correctly guided Khalifah! This proves that your Shia doctrine is a fabrication!

    There are so many questions that i can ask and leave you so clueless and make you realize that shia is nothing else than fabricated sector which has nothing to do with islam! Still not willing to accept that your sector is a cult? Well let me ask you the last question.

    Shias believe in an islamic pillar called Imamiyah (followers of the 12 imams)
    Where is the word “Imamiyah” mentioned in Quran?????????

    Your answer will be :
    *Well not all prophets names are written in quran
    *There is no way where it says how you perform salah
    *Imam Mehdi is also not mentioned in Quran
    *etc etc etc.

    Shias will do everything to turn the topic around here but will never answer the question.
    Well if not all prophets are mentioned in the quran, at least some are mentioned , right? At least the word PROPHET is mentioned!
    If its not mentioned how you perfome salah, well at least the world Salah has been mentioned like 90 times in the Quran!
    The word Angel is also mentioned in Quran!
    So all im asking is a very simple question , where is the word Immayah written in Quran? Im not even asking if the names of 12 imams are written in it, im just asking a very simple question of where is the word imamyah written?
    The answer is = There is no such word as immayah written in Quran! So will you accept it?

    Since you shias love questioning the al-he sunnah jamma. lets see wether you are capable of answering this question or will you turn the topic around just like another typical shia. This is a open challenge to any shia who can answer this question!

  10. Mubeen Moin said

    I want to share a Hadees to you all:

    Sahih Bukhari : Volume 9, Book 89, Number 329: Narrated Jabir bin Samura:

    I heard the Prophet saying, “There will be twelve Muslim rulers (who will rule all the Islamic world).” He then said a sentence which I did not hear. My father said, “All of them (those rulers) will be from Quraish.”

    You can verify it.

  11. answersforshiafriend said

    Walaykum Salam Brother,

    Please see the answer to question no 7 on this post. InshaAllah I will post another detailed reply to this soon, InshaAllah. In the mean while see the link below and read the answer to Qs no 7.

    https://answersforshiafriend.wordpress.com/2009/07/10/twenty-famous-questions-of-the-shia-that-converted-the-sunni-scholar/

  12. answersforshiafriend said

    Walaykum Salam Brother,

    Please see the answer to question no 7 on this post

    https://answersforshiafriend.wordpress.com/2009/07/10/twenty-famous-questions-of-the-shia-that-converted-the-sunni-scholar/

  13. assalamualaikum brother

    im looking for The Event of Pen and Paper coz the shias been bothering me with this issue plz help thx

  14. answersforshiafriend said

    Reply to Tijani’s lies in book here
    http://islamicweb.com/beliefs/cults/Taijani/

  15. mirza hannan said

    realy this site is ssssoooooo gooood and i like it…….ab shia khuch bhi kahe koi parwa nhi……or waise ab shia ko or bhane dhoond ne parenge……..

  16. Shani said

    Mashallah what a beautiful site, I’m really glad I found this site because I work with a Shia and he was always talking about the above events always attacking because I was a Sunni but after saying a few points from this site he can’t answer me and starts trying to avoid my question and changing the topic. Mashallah great work

  17. It is good that every one is going as a cross questioning and replying in a good manner whether they are shia or Sunni.Dear brothers no one can solve this difference.Remember this every time both we are muslim and we should never loose our unity anyhow in the sake of Islam.
    If you ask a Hindu or any other cast he will reply you only one answer that we are the right religion and best in the world.
    I am a shia person but never forget that every muslim is our brother.Carry on discussions with cool and proper way without hating each other.Allah hafiz

    Syed Zamin Ali Rizvi Hallauri
    Chitose Japan

  18. safdar said

    the author of this website is creating misunderstanding about shias in the mind of muslims who want to know the truth or about shias.iam a su nni but i have read & learnt a lot abt shias from our own sunni books & have come to the conclusion that a lot of statements & beliefs of shia are correct.the author of this website is creating hinderance in search of truth by confusing the reader ,i would request all readers to read the book of tijani samawi’s THEN I WAS GUIDED,samawi was a suuni before he became a follower of ahlul bayt.read this book and u can question sunni scholars who r hiding the truth or they themselves are not well read & infrmd.may Allah guide all of us on the right path.

  19. Alhumdulilah for this work! I am an American now living in Indonesia. I married a Muslimah who was born Indonesian and Muslim. I myself am a revert of five or so years. I realized early on in my Islam, that I must migrate to a Muslim majority country, so hence I ended up here. That is just to give you a short history of myself. When I first became Muslim, I was taught Islam by a Sunni brother. But I was curious of the other secs, such as, but not limited to, Shia-ism. I entered Islam with an open mind, and studied the different secs with an even more open mind. But even in my own Islams infancy, I knew that I hated Shia doctrine. When I met my wife, she being a Muslimah suspicious of me because I was American, wanted to confide in a Muslim brother of Pakistani decent. Her fear was justified because it is known that foreign men will pretend to be Muslim in order to marry Asian and Arab women, and even know as much Islam as they themselves do.

    In the beginning she wished that I speak with this “Muslim” brother in order to be sure I was honestly who I said I was. I was never afforded the opportunity to speak to him, because I had the money unnecessary to see her right away, and, Alhumdulilah, we were married about a month and a half after meeting.

    It was also Alhumdulilah that I never got to speak to him before hand, because I later found out that he was Shia. My dear wife only had little knowledge about Shia-ism, but I on the other hand had gained a lot from their own literature when I first converted. Therefore, I knew much about their twisted beliefs and practices. I used a lot of my knowledge to help guide my wife to a better understanding of what she was dealing with when it came to this individual. But this site was also very informative, and assisted me in having a broader understanding. Jihad is not always with a gun or a tank, but is also through knowledge. So may Allah SWT continue to guide you, and may He bless you in the Hereafter for even this little drop in the ocean of knowledge you have given us. Please feel free to contact me if you wish. I am always looking to become better informed in all things Islamic.

    May Allah SWT bless you!

  20. Dear Admin,

    Assalamualaikum Wrahmatullahi Wabarakatuh,

    MAHSAALLAH, m very much pleased with this website and its content are superb, xc-lent and mind blowing with true logic and authenticity. kind spread this website in whole muslim ummah to whom shia are misguiding our innocent muslims… May ALLAH SWT accept your working against Kuffar, Munafiqeen and Mushrik. i got lots of point in this website by which i will debate with some shia friends. May ALLAH SWT give you JAZA-E-KHAIR… AMEEN.

  21. U.Yaqoob said

    Subhanallah. I do not have the words to express my appreciation. What an amazing website with clear and concise information about Shiasm. A much needed source of authentic Islamic information , portraying the true message of Islam. May Allah accept your efforts and increase your knowledge and imaan. Inshallah I will be using this information to help defend our great Deen. Keep up the excellent work .May Allah guide us all on the ‘true’ path.Ameen

    JazakAllah Khairun

  22. mirza ali said

    the thing which had been removed by answersforshiafriend YOU CAN GO TO http://www.wabil.com AND ASK or you can go to http://www.shiaanswers.net also and ask.

  23. mirza ali said

    Brother answersforshiafriend
    Assalamu Alaykum,
    YOUR COMMENT HAS NOT PROVED THAT SHIASM IS A NEW RELIGION WHICH CAME INTO EXISTENCE MANY MANY YEARS AFTER THE DEATH OF PROPHET (S) SEE THE HISTORY OF ISLAM BEFORE COMMENTING .PROPHET MUHAMMAD (S) BOUGHT TO MANKIND WAS COMPLETE AND SUCH A GREAT MESSENGER WAS A SUCCESS BECAUSE NOT ALL WERE HIS CLOSEST COMPANIONS (AS ACCORDING TO US SHIAS) AND THE TRUE MUSLIMS WERE ONLY FEW IN NUMBER! THE PURPOSE OF SENDING MUHAMMAD S AS THE LAST MESSENGER INDEED ALLAH KNOWS THAT NO ONE NEEDS NEW RELIGION MOHAMMED(SAWS) BROUGHT THE TRUE MESSAGE BUT PEOPLE WHO YOU THINK ARE THE CLOSEST COMPANIONS WHERE HYPOCRATE THEY HAVE CHANGED THE RELIGION OF ALLAH(SWT) EVEN IN BATTLES LIKE UHAD PEOPLE LEFT THE PROPHET(SAWS) ALONE WHILE IMAM ALI (AS) WAS DEFENDING AND A FEW PEOPLE THE PURPOSE OF SENDING MUHAMMAD S AS THE LAST MESSENGER WAS TO GUIDE THE PEOPLE HE NEVER FAILED THOSE WHO WERE UNDERSTANDING THE RELIGION AND IT’S MESSAGE FOLLOWED ISLAM THEY CAME UP WITH TWELVE IMAMS WHO POSSESS THE QUALITIES OF MESSENGERS NOT MORE THAN HIM (SAWS) THEY ARE SAME AND PROPHET MOHAMMED(SAWS) HAS SAID THAT ALI AND ME ARE FROM ONE TREE HE ALSO SAID FIRST IS MOHAMMED LAST IS MOHAMMED MIDDLE IS MOHAMMED ALL ARE MOHAMMED SHIASM NEVER GIVES THEIR IMAMS GODLY QUALITIES OF ALLAH THERE IS NO ONE LIKE ALLAH (SWT) AND ABOUT AL KAFI THERE IS NO LIES IN IT MENTION IF ANY I REALLY THINK YOU ARE COMMENTING FOR THE SAKE OF COMMENTING AS FOR UMAR GOING TO SAKIFA AND COMING BACK IS THE A FOOLISHNESS THEN I ASK YOU IS THE BURIAL OF THE HOLY PROPHET MORE IMPORTANT THAN GOING TO SAKIFA? HE WANTED RASULALLAH SHOULD BE BURIED IN THE ROOM OF AISHA BECAUSE HE WANTED TO SHOW THE PEOPLE THAT HIS DAUGHTER WAS PIOUS LADY THE THE TRUTH IS THAT SHE WAS NOT AND ONLY HE SHOULD BE THE CALIPHATE OF THE MUSLIMS THEIR NAMES NOT MENTIONED HOLY BOOKS BUT THEIR GOOD MORALS ARE THERE IT IS OUR WORK TO FIND OUT WHO ARE THEY EVEN WHEN ADAM (AS) WAS ASKED THE NAMES OF PANJETAN 5 HE KNEW IT AND THE ANGLES DID NOT, THAT IS WHY IT IS OUR JOB TO IDENTIFY THEM THAT WHO ARE THEY THEY ARE MENTIONED IN (28:5) (11:86) (39:69) (2:2-3)(21:105) (24:55) (6:158) WHEN IMAM WILL REAPPEAR QURAN SAYS (17:81). I REALLY THINK YOU ARE COMMENTING FOR THE SAKE OF COMMENTING YOU ARE NOT TRYING TO FIND OUT WHICH IS THE TRUTH YOU ARE JUST TRYING TO DEFEND YOURSELF SHIAISM HAS EXPLANATION FOR EVERYTHING IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTION YOU CAN GO TO [removed] AND ASK .

  24. answersforshiafriend said

    Brother Mirza.. Assalamu Alaykum,
    Your comment has again proved that Shiasm is a new religion which came into existence many many years after the death of Prophet (S)

    If shiasm is to be believed, then no doubt it proves that the message that Prophet Muhammad (s) bought to mankind was incomplete and such a great messenger was a total failure(naauzobillah) because all of his closest companions (as according to you shias) apostated nauzobillah and the true Muslims were only few in number! So whats the purpose of sending Muhammad s as the last messenger IF he failed and his true message was corrupted.. surely then you need a new messenger.

    When is comes to this.. shiaism has no explanation.. so they came up with twelve imams who possess the qualities of messengers… infact even more ..shiasm gives their imams GODLY qualities of ALLAH in total opposition of Quran and commit open shirk

    Secondly, you shias have been ‘fed’ this twisted history of islam which is nothing but fabrications which is only found in YOUR history books which were written 100s of years after even your twelfth imam died. Infact the hadith book that you claim to follow ‘Al Kafi’ was said to be written during the time of the hidden twelfth imam and shown to him who approved it.. but it has many many errors and lies and filth. and if we ask you who wrote these filthy books of yours.. the Al Kafi and Bihar ul anwar.. you have no details about them. You just blindly believe what these unknown people wrote claiming to be shia books!

    What you shias say what happend at the burial of Prophet Muhammad s is far from truth.

    Abu Bakr and Umar (r) went to saqifa and then returned back to take part in the funeral preparations.It was Abu Bakar who informed the other companions that Prophets are buried where they die and that RasulAllah should be buried in the room of Aisha where he died. The question is is there any evidence to proof that they were not part of the funeral preparations??!! and The question is: Is there any evidence that there were chain of non-prophet successors from a prophet, all being infallible, all being in the same generation? With no mention of their names in their holy books? Is there any evidence that one of them goes to occultation for centuries while still being in this world? The question and any replies to it has nothing to do with proving that 12ers Shia is the right version of Islam.

    You sunnis.. please read up the hadiths in Bukhari and Muslim where Hazrat Umar (r) was totally in denial of the death of our Rasool (s) due to grief and how Abu Bakr (r) quoted a verse of the Quran …Please read :
    Saqifa: The truth

  25. mirza ali said

    we discuss and explain events like

    •Ghadir Khumm
    •Burial of Prophet Muhammad sallalahu alayhe wasallam
    •Issue of Fadak
    •The Event of Pen and Paper
    •The Event of the Saqifa
    •The hadith of the cloak
    •Attack ont he door of Fatima (s.a)
    •Fatima’s anger with Abu Bakar radiallhu anhum
    •The Battle of Siffin and Battle of Jamal
    •Tragedy of Karbala
    •Attitude of Muawiyah and Yazid
    because these are the main topics in the history of islam these events show the show off shaba of the prophet who use it to defend themself’s by showing they are shaba of the prophet and who are the true shaba of the prophet
    even you people know that during the Burial of Prophet Muhammad sallalahu alayhe wasallam your first 3 Caliphate were busy thinking who would be the khilāfa while imam ali(a.s) and true shabas were giving ghusl, kafan ,to Prophet Muhammad sallalahu alayhe wasallam …[

  26. nice of u sir u solved a lot of my probs may allah bless u.

  27. Muslim said

    Well done brother, Good blog
    But dont you feel that just to prove your point of view you are misleading some where as I came to know through many shia I know and through their books as well that their is so concept of worshipping any of 12 Imams. Tawheed is the base for all who says thay are Muslim and Shia are not exception. Please put something more relevent and true, otherwise it looks you are not sure yourself about what are you writing, Which makes even your right statemens suspicious.

  28. Alhamdulliah,for many days I have come across filthy materials concocted by shias against Sunnis.You have so far done a great job.Keep it up.You are doing brilliantly well.I am very much impressed.

    Jazak allah kher
    Sayed Faiz Tanvir

  29. m.bilal said

    thnx brother, my room mate is a shia and he bothers me too much whith his questions, which were out of my knowledge but now i understand his intentions.

  30. sadiq said

    Assalmualikum brother,
    first of all let me say mashallah on this blog. being raised as a mainstream muslim (of indian roots) and coming to study in university (i was born and live in uk) i met many shia muslims from iran but had no idea where the differences in belief came from. i would love to contact you somehow and continue this discussion in email as i think this is a very important issue especially within universities in the uk. in particular there is a problem of certain lax shia muslims drinking alcohol and sleeping around with women etc giving other orthodox muslims the impression that this sort of behaviour is acceptable when i am sure even in the shia game plan as you said, this would not be part of it. this leads to further division. as i always say, muslims go one ofn two ways when they hit uni, either they go super religious and become very devout, usually at the expense of dawa with non muslims (alhamdulliah this is getting better now) or they go the opposite and when not under their parents watchful eye begin partying, drinking, sleeping around and doing drugs.

    where are you based by the way? i would surely love to recommend this blog to many mainstream muslims curious about shia islam and how they do what they do and why mainstream islam is the only path to jannah inshallah

    thanks again, please feel free to contact me on the email i provided

    Jazakallah Khair

    Sadiq

  31. Muhammad Zubair said

    very good brother
    Allah Bless You

  32. irananaliz said

    Very nice, effective and realistic blog. Congraluations! It is very important to reveal real face and insidious projects of Iran which is a heretical bidah madhab as policy in the country.

  33. Shiraz said

    shiasim is not a religion but just a version of “JUDIASIM” to corrupt islam

  34. Shiraz said

    Asalam o Alakum.

    great work has been done to show the real face of Shiasim. they ar not just voilating ALLAH and his Prophet (P.B.U.H)but also Hazrat Ali (R.A). May Allah guide us all towards the right path of Tauheed and Sunna.

  35. adeel said

    ASSALAM-O-ALAIKUM

    I ONLY WANT TO SAY THAT SHIAS ARE ONLY MUSLIM WHO NEVER DEFEATED BY ANY ONE AT ANY PLACE IN ANY ISSUE.
    MAJORITY OF SUNNI SCHOLARS ACCEPT THE SUPERIORITY OF SHIA BELIEFS IN ALL FACTORS OF ISLAM.

    THERE ARE HUNDREDS THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE WHO HAVE SELECTED SHIASM AND ARE SELECTING.

  36. khizar said

    I want to know about death and burieng procedure in shia islam. give answere

  37. Mohammed said

    Assalamualaikum
    This website is absolutely brilliant and has taught me a lot about shias. It shows all the weaknesses in Shia arguements very well.
    Masha Allah well done!

  38. Arshia said

    Dear Brothers & Sisters in islam,
    May Almighty Allah guide you for this works. I have no words to appreciate the answers you have provided.It is very easy to become shia,its very hard to follow a right path.I am sufeferin in this problem,as it has ruied my mental peace. I thank Almighty Allah for removin me from that.Pray that my family also comes out of this.
    So many convert to shia,but none to muslim. Maybe Allah has sealed they heart.
    After ramazan i will join your forum,and help you in your work.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: